6 Comments
Sep 18Liked by Motley Fool

Really great article! The mechanics of a joust are amazing.

Expand full comment
author

Thank you. I'm not really a detailed mechanics guy and, no doubt, if my back-of-a-fag-packet efforts were subjected to any serious mathematical or statistical scrutiny they would be found severely wanting. But they feel sort of OK and - hopefully - give enough of a sense for someone more competent than I to make a proper fist of it.

Expand full comment
Sep 18Liked by Motley Fool

I saved the article just in case I decide to make a mini game out of jousting. 😊

Expand full comment
author
Sep 18·edited Sep 18Author

I don't warrant their actual effectivenes. I only playtested them a few times - certainly not long enough to reveal any weird outliers that could happen. But if you make use of them, let me know how they played out.

Expand full comment

What a fantastic breakdown, and hilarious to read the weekend after visiting New York Ren Faire. I wonder two thing:

1. Is a system of randomization an attributes the best way to work this out in TTRPGs? Sure, it's the way things are usually done -- you have a certain ability score, you roll a check, you reference a result. But I wonder if there is some other way to simulate the moment, like some sort of bluffing game, or a game like blackjack or something?

2. Cliche question: How do you feel about the way Pendragon deals with this?

Expand full comment

What a fantastic breakdown, and hilarious to read the weekend after visiting New York Ren Faire. I wonder two thing:

1. Is a system of randomization an attributes the best way to work this out in TTRPGs? Sure, it's the way things are usually done -- you have a certain ability score, you roll a check, you reference a result. But I wonder if there is some other way to simulate the moment, like some sort of bluffing game, or a game like blackjack or something?

2. Cliche question: How do you feel about the way Pendragon deals with this?

Expand full comment